العلامة الشيخ محمد عيسى عبيد المصري
(المتوفى سنة 1383 ھ)
في كتابه (دلائل التنزيه وإبطال عقيدة التجسيم والتشبيه)
قال في بيان حال رأس المشبهة ابن تيمية ما نصه :
” ذلك الحراني هو أبو العباس أحمد بن عبد الحليم
المشهور بابن تيمية المتوفى سنة 728 ھ، تجرد للدعوة إلى مذهب الحشوية متظاهرًا بالجمع بين العقل والنقل على حسب فهمه من الكتب بدون أستاذ رشيد يحذره مواطن الزلل.
وحاشا العقل السليم والنقل الصحيح أن يدافعا عن أوهام المُشبهة.
وكم غّر أُناسًا جهلوا أصول الدين فوقعوا في حباله.
وأنّى يوجد نص صريح منقول أو برهان صحيح معقول يثبت الجهة والحركة والمكان
ونحوها لمن ليس كمثله شيئ وهو الملك القدوس السلام المتعالي عن شبه المخلوقين!! “.
ويقول في ابن تيمية أيضًا :
” نعم هو إمام المشبهة وشيخ المجسمة وقدوة الذين يتبعون ما تشابه من التنزيل.
قاده شيطانه إلى النيل من كل إمام في الدين معاصر له أو سابق عليه حتى لم يسلم من لسانه الصحابة رضوان الله عليهم “
English:
The scholar Shaykh Muhammad ‘Isa ‘Ubayd al-Misri (d. 1383 AH), in his book Dalail al-Tanzih wa Ibtal ‘Aqidat al-Tajsim wa al-Tashbih (Proofs of Divine Transcendence and Refutation of the Belief in Anthropomorphism and Likeness), commented on the condition of the leader of the anthropomorphists, Ibn Taymiyyah. He said:
“That Harranian is Abu al-‘Abbas Ahmad ibn ‘Abd al-Halim, known as Ibn Taymiyyah, who died in 728 AH. He devoted himself to advocating for the creed of the Hashawiyyah (a sect accused of anthropomorphism), outwardly claiming to reconcile reason and revelation according to his understanding of the books, without a wise teacher to warn him of the pitfalls.”
“And far be it from sound reason and authentic revelation to defend the illusions of the anthropomorphists.
How many people, ignorant of the fundamentals of religion, have been deceived and ensnared by their traps!
How could there ever exist a clear, authentic text or a sound, rational proof to establish attributes such as spatial direction, movement, or place for the One who is unlike anything in existence?
He also says about Ibn Taymiyyah:
“Indeed, he is the imam of the anthropomorphists, the leader of the corporealists, and the exemplar for those who follow the ambiguous aspects of the revelation.”
Portuguese:
O erudito Shaykh Muhammad ‘Isa ‘Ubayd al-Misri (falecido em 1383 AH), em seu livro Dalail al-Tanzih wa Ibtal ‘Aqidat al-Tajsim wa al-Tashbih (Provas da Transcendência Divina e Refutação da Crença no Antropomorfismo e Assemelhação), comentou sobre a condição do líder dos antropomorfistas, Ibn Taymiyyah. Ele disse:
“Esse harraniano é Abu al-‘Abbas Ahmad ibn ‘Abd al-Halim, conhecido como Ibn Taymiyyah, que faleceu em 728 AH. Ele se dedicou a defender a crença dos Hashawiyyah (uma seita acusada de antropomorfismo), alegando aparentemente reconciliar a razão e a revelação de acordo com sua compreensão dos livros, sem um professor sábio que o alertasse sobre as armadilhas.”
“E está muito longe da razão saudável e da revelação autêntica defender as ilusões dos antropomorfistas.
Quantas pessoas, ignorantes dos fundamentos da religião, foram enganadas e caíram em suas armadilhas!
Como poderia existir um texto claro e autêntico ou uma prova racional e sólida que estabeleça atributos como direção espacial, movimento ou lugar para Aquele que não se assemelha a nada existente?
Ele também diz sobre Ibn Taymiyyah:
“De fato, ele é o imã dos antropomorfistas, o líder dos que atribuem corporeidade a Deus e o exemplo para aqueles que seguem os aspectos ambíguos da revelação.”
موقع لطائف التنبيهات 